The Secular Restructuring

The mortgage industry is no longer in a cyclical downturn; it is undergoing a permanent restructuring. The era of easy refinance volume has ended, replaced by a market characterized by macroeconomic stagnation and a fundamental shift in borrower psychology.

The market has bifurcated into two distinct classes. The financial penalty of trading a 3% rate for a 7% rate has decimated discretionary relocation—creating what industry insiders call "golden handcuffs."

The Haves
Homeowners with pre-2022 mortgages locked in.
Typical rate: under 4%
The Have-Nots
New buyers and movers purchasing today.
Typical rate: north of 6%

The Data of Stagnation

Repeat Buyer Participation
Down 31%
compared to 2018–2019 levels
FTHB Dominance
58%
of agency purchase lending
Production Profit
$950
per loan in Q2 2025, historically thin

The Strategic Takeaway

A business model dependent solely on origination volume is existentially fragile. Lenders must decouple profitability from the volatility of interest rate cycles.